Best Toaster Oven Reviews 2015

Pin It

Many toaster oven reviews treat this handy, all-purpose small appliance as a multi-function toaster. That is, they rate the consistency of “browning” and the number of slices it holds is discussed, but many other great features are left in the dark.

Ironically, toasting bread is the least useful activity you can perform with a toaster oven. A toaster oven is used for so much more than toasting bread. In fact, Unless you’re cooking for a large group, it’s very tedious to toast bread in a toaster oven. That’s because it takes up to ten minutes to make toast in a toaster oven. That is almost twice as long to toast bread in a toaster oven than a regular toaster!

For the energy-conscious, this is a nightmare of inefficiency. For the rest of us, it’s a long, slow, tedious wait in the morning, just to get a slice of toast.

Therefore, we’ll begin this, second in our series of toaster oven reviews, by saying straight out:

If all you need is to toast bread or bagels, stick with a regular toaster. If you want an auxiliary oven that can do many things and save you time and money on your utility bills, go for a toaster oven.

Recommended Toaster Ovens

For More Insight About Choosing the Right Toaster Oven Check Out Our Full Site

We offer more than reviews- take a quick moment:

  1. Popular Toaster Ovens Reviews
  2. Quick-reference Comparison Charts so you get a quick handle on toaster oven choices
  3. Types of Toaster Ovens
  4. A Handy How-To-Guide on all things Toaster Oven

Toaster Oven Reviews That Are Actually Useful

One thing you’ll notice in most toaster oven reviews is the enormous range of features, quality and functionality to choose from…not to mention the pricing, which ranges from $30 to $250! That’s because just about every company that’s in the small appliances business makes their own version of what they consider to be the top toaster oven.

What you’ll find different here however, is that we’ve narrowed the field a bit: the toaster oven reviews you’ll see below are the best of the best. This is for the luxury goods consumer who wants the absolute best toaster oven from the top brands. In the case of toaster ovens, these would be Cuisinart and Breville, both considered the Cadillacs of the small appliance world.

When you’re in the high end appliance realm, you’re looking for superior design that makes the item not only look pretty slick but also adds intuitive functionality and genius features that make cooking pleasurable, safe, and hassle-free.

Among all our toaster oven reviews, this is one is the one to consult if you want a top of the line machine. It covers the high-end market items, made by Cuisinart, Breville, Black & Decker, Hamilton Beach and Oster, which not only do a superb job at cooking your food, but also come with some of the “genius” features and brilliant design that you might expect in this price range and quality level.

Comparison of Best Toaster Ovens 2015

Breville BOV450XL

Breville BOV650XL

Breville BOV800XL

Cuisinart TOB-40

Cuisinart TOB-195
4.5 Stars
4.1 Stars4.4 Stars3.7 Stars4.5 Stars
Capacity0.45 cubic-foot0.6 cubic-foot0.8 cubic-foot0.6 cubic-foot0.6 cubic-foot
Amazon Reviews872+979+3336+2338+737+
Dimensions inches15.5L x 14W x 8.8H16.5L x 15.5W x 10.25H18.5L x 16.2W x 11.2H15.9L x 11.8W x 7.9H18.5L x 16.9W x 10H
Pizza Capacity11 Inches12 Inches12 Inches11Inches12 Inches
Digital ControlsYesYesYesNoYes
Warranty1 year1 year1 year3 Years3 years
Get DiscountGet DiscountGet DiscountGet DiscountGet Discount

Back to top

Our Popular Articles:

Toaster Oven Recipes

Mini Pizzas

Shrimp Casserole

Chicken Recipe

Dessert Recipes

Types of Toaster Ovens

Infrared Toaster Ovens

Considered specialty ovens or a specialty feature, infrared toaster ovens use infrared technology to cook food…heat is transferred directly to the food (regular ovens heat the air around the food to cook it). They save on energy and there’s no preheating required, pretty nifty.

Infrared cooking also cooks food 50% faster and you don’t have to defrost frozen food. It’s also very good at crisping. The machines in our toaster oven reviews below are not infrared toaster ovens.

Rotisserie Toaster Ovens

These come with an attachment that holds meat and spins it slowly as it cooks. The machines in our toaster oven reviews below are not rotisserie toaster ovens.


Convection cooking forces air around the oven to cook food more efficiently. They save up to 50% of energy over regular ovens.

Factors to Consider When Buying The Best Toaster Ovens


Your typical oven capacity is .5 cubic feet, and can hold 4-6 slices of toast. If you want to roast a chicken or cook a 12-inch pizza, look for the one that’s slightly larger: 3/5 cubic foot (.6 cubic foot) is enough for those purposes.


Your basic toaster oven will bake, broil and toast. The best toaster oven, on the other hand, will also do the following:

  • reheat
  • defrost
  • roast
  • fit a 12″ pizza
  • fit a dozen cookies

Your average toaster oven should last you about 5 years. A top toaster oven from a high end manufacturer, on the other hand, should last you quite a bit longer.


Most toaster oven reviews will tell you to look for consistent browning, for those occasions when you will toast bread. This can be expanded: look for an oven which has consistent heating during baking as well. The best toaster oven will have very few hot spots so as to deliver even cooking.


The best toaster oven for you will have the features you need without making you pay for features you don’t want. That’s why it’s wise to do your research first- our toaster oven reviews are designed to give you all the pointers you need to make a smart purchase. Here’s a handy list of features to consider when searching for your top toaster oven:

  • Interior Light
  • Automatic Shutoff
  • Cool Touch Exterior
  • Automatic Ejection Tray
  • “Ready” Sound Alert
  • LED Indicators
  • Slide out tray
  • Multiple Racks
  • Nonstick or Porcelain Interior
  • Easy Cleanup
  • Slide Out Crumb Tray
  • Bagel Setting
  • Baking Pan Included

Back to top

Top Rated Toaster Ovens Review

Breville BOV450XL Mini Smart Oven Review

Breville BOV450XL oven toasterThe smallest of Breville’s hugely popular Smart Oven series, the Mini Smart Oven contains all the features of Breville’s top toaster oven (see below) but in the tiniest size for small kitchens. The 0.45 cu ft. interior makes it perfect for your urban apartment, beach house or dorm room. The 450 XL has a beautiful powder coated steel exterior that fits with any design. Gorgeous good looks are only the beginning, however. Premium level features include:

  • Three positions to choose from for your oven rack
  • Auto shut off
  • 8 preset cooking functions (see details in the next review)
  • 11 inch pizza capacity
  • Just as powerful as its two larger cousins, reviewed below

You get Smart Oven technology, Breville quality and premium level features all for a much lower price than the full sized Smart Oven. What are you giving up? Mainly size…toaster oven reviews will all tell you that the larger the oven, the more it costs. But you’re also giving up a broil pan, pizza pan and other non-essentials like a silver color, auto-eject wire rack and one less pre-set function than the full size model. The basics:

  • .45 cubic foot capacity
  • 11″ pizza
  • 3 rack positions
  • 8 pre-set functions

For full specifications and more Breville BOV450XL toaster oven reviews visit here or check out our detailed review page here.
Back to top

Breville BOV650XL Compact Smart Toaster Oven Review

brevillebov 650xl oven toasterWhen look at the best toaster oven, you get what we like to call “genius features”, which are elements of design so perfect and useful they simply make cooking a pleasure. One of these is the LCD screen on the Smart Oven series. Like all the Smart Ovens, the back-lit LCD screen is orange during cooking and magically turns blue when your food is done. Another great thing about the LCD: you can change the number of slices of bread you’re toasting on the readout, and the oven will adjust its setting to brown them evenly and perfectly every time. Now that’s a premium feature. This BOV650XL model is the medium-sized Smart Oven:

  • 3/5 cubic foot capacity
  • 12″ pizza
  • 3 rack positions
  • 8 pre-set functions
  • This Smart Oven comes with 10×10 inch enamel baking pan & 10 x 10 inch enamel broil rack.

The Smart Oven series also come with wonderfully handy pre-set functions. This model and the 450 XL reviewed above have 8 functions (the 800XL, below, has 9), including:

  1. One-side toasting function.
  2. Pizza function.
  3. Cookie function.
  4. Reheat function.

There’s a handy rack position helper stamped on the front glass of the oven door. This essentially takes the guessing out of how to cook most items. It’s just one more example of intuitive design you’d expect from a top toaster oven like this one. Here’s another: the temperature conversion button converts Fahrenheit to Celsius.

For full specifications and more Breville BOV650XL toaster oven reviews visit here or check out our detailed review page here.

Breville BOV800XL Convection Toaster Review

Breville BOV800XL toaster ovenIf you’ve read other toaster oven reviews, you’ll already you’ll already know that the Breville Smart Oven is considered by most to be the top toaster oven in its class. Here we have the full sized model, and the only one of these three that has convection functionality. In addition to having everything the other two Smart Ovens have, it also comes with one extra pan: a pizza pan. You’ll know why when you discover that this wonderful machine can handle a thirteen inch pizza. That’s pretty rare, even among the best toaster ovens.

  • 4/5 cubic foot capacity
  • 13″ pizza
  • 3 rack positions
  • 9 pre-set functions

For full specifications, and more Breville BOV800XL Convection Toaster reviews visit here or check out our detailed review page here.

Cuisinart TOB-40 Custom Classic Toaster Oven Broiler Review

cuisinart tob-40 toaster ovenIt’s almost unfair to compare anything to the ultra deluxe Smart Ovens by Breville, but if you’d rather spend a little less and still get a top toaster oven then go with this Cuisinart, the TOB-40 Custom Classic. It comes with premium features but costs one-third as much. Here’s what you get:

  • 4/5 cubic foot capacity, yet small footprint
  • 11″ pizza, 6 slices of toast
  • Nonstick Interior
  • 1800 Watts (like all the Smart Ovens) means fast heating, no warm-up time
  • Front-loading crumb tray
  • Auto-slide out tray
  • Comes with oven rack, broiling rack, drip pan
  • 3 years limited warranty- that’s amazing

For full specifications and more Cuisinart TOB-40 Toaster Oven reviews visit here or check out our detailed review page here.

Cuisinart TOB-195 Exact Heat Toaster Oven Broiler Stainless Toaster Oven Review

cuisinart tob195 toaster oven reviewThe TOB-195 is an upgrade from the previous model and considered the best toaster oven made by Cuisinart. The gorgeous looks alone are enough to drive many style-conscious consumers to crave this oven for their kitchen. It features a brushed stainless steel exterior with a commercial-style bar handle across the top, and electronic touch pad controls. Here’s what else you get:

  • 0.6 cubic foot capacity
  • 12″ pizza, 6 slices of toast
  • Fits 12 x 12 pan
  • 1500 Watts- less than all other models reviewed here
  • 3-year limited warranty

For full specifications, and more Cuisinart TOB-195 Toaster Oven reviews visit here.
Back to top

Our Verdict

If you can afford it, the full-sized Smart Oven by Breville is certainly the best toaster oven we’ve seen to hit the market in years. The long list of premium features, the “Genius Level” design and the range of functions, combined with ease of use that make it easy for anyone to use this oven, make it a clear winner in every category (except of course price).

But if you need value, the Cuisinart TOB-4o Custom Classic is considered the best toaster oven Cuisinart makes. It delivers more power than the TOB-195, has premium features, and holds up well with customers in toaster oven reviews across the board. We loved the shade control, extra large crumb tray and the handy bagel function setting.

Pin It